
BICYCLE HELMET RESEARCH FOUNDATION		cyclehelmets.org
Home Page	Main Topics	Analysis	Search Site	Full Index

If car occupants must wear seat belts, why shouldn't cyclists wear helmets?

Cars and seat belts differ from bikes and bicycle helmets in three key ways:

Seat belts provide far better protection to car occupants (72% fatality reduction in head-on crashes, for example [1]) than helmets provide for bicyclists (no proven reduction for fatal or disabling head injuries [2]).
Helmet laws, and to a lesser extent helmet promotion, make cycling less safe by discouraging the activity and thereby undercutting safety in numbers. There are no such analogous effects for driving.
By discouraging cycling, helmet laws suppress both the individual and societal health benefits of cycling, both of which are considerable [3]. There is no such analogous effect for driving.

The combination of these three factors not only destroys the attempted analogy, it makes it more likely that bicycle helmet laws will cost lives rather than save them.

See also:	Relative risk in cycling
	Key facts about injury when cycling in perspective
	How safe is cycling? - an informative quiz

References

[1] Crandall CS, Olson LM, Sklar DP. Mortality Reduction with Air Bag and Seat Belt Use in Head-on Passenger Car Collisions. American Journal of Epidemiology, 2001;153(30:219-224.
[2] see: What evidence is there that cycle helmets save lives? and What evidence is there that cycle helmets reduce serious injury?
[3] see: The health benefits of cycling.

Main Topics	www.cyclehelmets.org	Search site
Published by the Bicycle Helmet Research Foundation, which exists to undertake, encourage and spread the scientific study of bicycle helmets and to provide access to a wide range of information to assist the understanding of this complex subject. Most information published on www.cyclehelmets.org has been subjected to multi-disciplinary peer review. Material is copyright BHRF, but may be reproduced provided this is done in full, without modification, and the source is acknowledged.